This month sees the publication of Young Lives, Young Futures: Understanding Opportunities and Challenges in Post-School Transitions in England, the last in a series of reports on six years of Economic and Social Research Council-funded research, It explores how the 50% of young people in England who don’t go to university navigate the years between school and adulthood. It draws on the perspectives of 4,295 young people, tracking their journeys between the ages of 15-16 and 19-20, from their final year of compulsory schooling into post-16 education, apprenticeships, employment, and unemployment. Young people not only contributed to this study, but through a youth advisory group, fed into our research design from day one. Their input revealed an institutional architecture fundamentally misaligned with their needs.
One standout finding from this research is that schools are poorly designed for young people who don’t attend university. Since Michael Gove’s curriculum reforms, schools have become far more exam-orientated – continuous assessment scrapped in favour of exams at 16 and the accountability system pushing out creative subjects in favour of ‘more valuable’ core subjects like maths, English and the sciences. This relentless focus also reduces teacher time for pastoral care. Reducing required content would benefit all young people, whatever their pathway. Most careers advice in schools is geared toward university, with far less support around apprenticeships, vocational and other non-university routes. Following abolition of the Connexions service – which gave young people access to independent and impartial professional guidance – responsibility for careers advice was delegated to schools. But schools often lack the necessary expertise and are ill-placed to give neutral advice while their funding remains tied to learner numbers. A new national, independent careers service is urgently needed to ensure all post-16 pathways receive equal weight.
Nuanced views on the ‘NEET crisis’ also came through strongly. Policies aimed at reducing the number of young people classified as NEET typically emphasise getting them into work, but fail to consider the quality of that work. The approximately 8% of young people who participate in apprenticeships by age 20 reported largely positive experiences – including a sense of being cared for in their workplaces, being given autonomy and voice, and deriving fulfilment from their work. But secure employment among 19-20-year-olds has fallen from over 80% of those in work six years ago to just 50% of those in work today. Many young people leave jobs due to overwork, poor pay, a lack of autonomy, bullying and harassment, or because they can’t afford the commute. Policy should not simply funnel young people into work, but consider how to improve its quality.
Those with mental health conditions lasting 12+ months at 15-16 were also far more likely to remain NEET at 19-20. Policy often focuses on supporting young people whose mental health prevents them from working or attending school, but not on how school and work themselves may be contributing to that deterioration. Conscious attention and planning are needed to help promote mental well-being and prevent mental ill-health in school and work settings.
Underpinning all this is a broader story about inequality.All the issues described here are amplified for those experiencing disadvantage. Young people from low-income households or with special educational needs feel less well-supported at school and have poorer access to good quality work and apprenticeships. Young people from Black and Asian backgrounds and those born outside the UK apply for apprenticeships at the same rates as White and UK-born, but are significantly less likely to be selected – a barrier at the point of employer selection, not of aspiration. Our research showed that around 60% of those classed as NEET were actively seeking education/employment, with a further 11% doing unpaid caring or voluntary work. They are not disengaged.
Our report includes a number of recommendations. One priority is employment rights education. We are already working with partners to design resources that schools and colleges can use to teach young people about their rights, empowering them once they find employment. We also need a cultural shift in conversations around work, away from reducing the welfare bill towards what kind of work young people want and need.
Another key lever for change will be transforming the school accountability system. The YLYF team has received further funding from the ESRC, matched by Edge, for a proof-of-concept pilot of a new accountability approach. This will involve working with a multi-academy trust to trial a model where school communities have more say over what schools are held accountable for, backed by critical feedback from a peer team of other school communities. Ofsted’s role would shift to inspecting the accountability systems of local authorities and trusts, rather than inspecting schools directly. Such a model is much more likely to be formative and developmental, rather than punitive
The principal message, though, is the importance of centring young people’s agency in policymaking. Whether in curriculum design, careers guidance, vocational pathways or employment quality, young people must be involved in the decisions that shape their lives
If the system is more democratic, they won’t have to endure policies imposed upon them – they’ll be in a position to meaningfully contribute to a system that works for them, and for society as a whole.
Written by
Sharon Gewirtz, Professor of Education in the School of Education, Communication & Society at King's College London, and Principal Investigator on Young Lives, Young Futures.